I am dying to know which one you're referring to.
I feel like this for most of the comics I draw (except for a few, and sometimes the responses aren't that good for them, which is also funny!), but among the recent ones....I think the "German guy thing" was pretty meh. Or even "Gachunk". I dunno! And then I look at them a little differently when people react positively to the ones I thought were sucky, which is really interesting!